On My Grind

This is not your parents' business blog! Welcome to On My Grind-- discussing business, social responsibility, productivity, and more.

Subscribe to OMG
Twitter
Search
« Mashable and 92Y's Social Good Summit Recap | Main | Hell Yes, I Take a Lunch Break! »

Before you Enroll in Grad School, Consider this. We're in an Education Bubble.

Here in the US, we have this traditional model for education. The one where you get your Bachelor's, probably a Master's too, and massive amounts of debt. While technology is becoming increasingly important in every aspect of life, your classes are probably going to use outdated methods to teach you. Then the only time you seek more education is when you or your company pays for some expensive professional development class or certification training. Maybe you'll also attend a conference at a hotel where no one really learns anything, and all parties involved have a wasted a lot of money for you to sit around and consume the burnt coffee and subpar food. But you did get away from the office for a couple of days, which is delightful, because you hate your job.

This model is dying. Or if it's not in fact dying, it needs to. I'm supposedly part of this progressive (and notorious) "Generation Y", yet save a few, we're also still stuck in this last century thinking. Our parents and grandparents have always emphasized the importance of a college education, but does this mindset still make sense now that a degree is worth so much less compared to just a few decades ago? The people who are making money are the ones who thought outside the box, the creators. In these not-so-rosy economic times, we're witnessing a vicious cycle of young people unable to get the work they want, so they pay insane tuition and fees to go back to school. They believe another degree is the answer. After graduation, when they need money more than ever to pay back their loans, they still can't find an ideal job. Now the labor pool is flooded with people who have postgraduate degrees and are desperate for work. Employers are overwhelmed with the number of applicants and, in response, demand higher qualifications as a way to filter the applications. Yet higher education institutions continue selling something that doesn't exist-- a guarantee of a better future. Something's gotta give. 

We are in a higher education bubble, and it's going to burst soon. Colleges need to rethink the way they do business and how they educate their students, instead of giving them false hope that postgraduate degrees are an "investment" and that companies will be lining up to hire them. They need to do a better job of giving their students the tools and skills they need for the real world, at a cheaper price. I have faith that academic leaders are becoming more savvy and will come up with a better model, but it's not going to be a quick fix.

My peers get extremely defensive when I talk about this, because most of them went for postgraduate degrees. It isn't their fault, and they shouldn't regret it if their degree didn't get them the job they wanted. This isn't about individual cases. This is a far bigger problem. It's a national belief, and we're all seduced by colleges' promises of awesome job opportunities. There are definitely some postgraduate programs that are exceptions, but overall, higher education as it is right now is not sustainable. The system will, and has to, change. People are going to keep buying into it for the time being regardless, but at least stop and really weigh your options before you jump into an expensive postgraduate program just because you don't like your job. The slow transformation of higher education may not be in your control, but there is plenty of other things you can do to better yourself, and even better the world.

 

You might think this is your cue to use colleges/the economy/Wall Street/"the man" as your excuse to do nothing. There are other things you can do besides going back to school. Check back next week-- I'll be making some suggestions on what you can do.

 

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (6)

Thanks for this insightful blog, Iris. I totally relate to everything you are saying about post-grad degrees and the struggle of our generation to find a successful career and being pushed toward grad degrees as a means of getting there. I've delayed grad school because of the price but still intend on at least going for my master's. Your blog doesn't exactly give me confidence to do this! I'm curious how it is that you've developed such a clear insight into this?

September 14, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterJennifer

Wonderfully written. Sometimes I wonder if attending grad school for money is the best decision. Instead of more schooling, students need to realize which career fits him or her best. If I wanted to go to college to learn more skills, I'd probably just go to a vocational college. Right now, the problem is price and the content of our classes. What are the teachers truly teaching us? Why is the price so high? As an artist, it's important for me to grasp the philosophical or conceptual ideas behind a piece of art. Now I'll need techniques to express these ideas so I'll go to workshops. I like the idea of low-residency programs- no classes, but more guidance. Bard College and Lesley University have these sort of programs, but still the price is pretty expensive. Basically, I wish there was a grad school with the same price as a vocational college.

September 14, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterTiffany Joy Butler

Jennifer - Don't let this post stop you from your plans! I just want to remind people not to rush into anything. So many people use grad school as an escape plan from something else. Do consider your financial plan for paying for a program, what you will realistically get out of it (sometimes not as much as you'd hope), and whether or not you really need it for what you want to do. If you've weighed all the real facts and still think it makes sense to do, go for it!

These are just my observations from working in higher ed and having so many peers that went to postgraduate school, and from following recent economic events!

September 20, 2011 | Registered CommenterIris

Tiffany - Thanks Tiffany! Yea I think art is definitely a tricky one. On one hand an extensive education sounds necessary for people who will eventually go on to teach art (which is many people I guess?) but then I wonder if it's necessary for just straight artists. Can they not get by with self-education, workshops/courses, and producing lots and lots of art? Doing and practicing is what makes you en expert after all, not sitting in classes for two years. But as I don't know anything about art, that's just my outsider perspective. Do enlighten me :)

But if neither path will make an artist a lot of money (unless one becomes famous), why is a MFA so damned expensive?

September 20, 2011 | Registered CommenterIris

Nice post! I totally agree with you! I think the big problem is not necessarily going for a grad degree as much as the cost. I think getting a grad degree somewhere in Canada or Europe for way cheaper might be a better plan. And it's not just grad degrees, even undergrad is way too overvalued, especially for the kind of jobs that are out there. Although it's not just an American problem, Chinese kids just out of college are working for pennies, and the more kids with degrees out there, the less the pay becomes. Right now factory workers are making more than recent grads.

September 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterSean

Thanks, Sean! Didn't realize something similar was happening over there, given the way people talk about China's booming business and economy. I'm also with you on undergraduate degrees being overvalued/overrated too. Can't say I was any more prepared to enter the workforce as a college graduate than as a high school graduate.

September 23, 2011 | Registered CommenterIris
Comments for this entry have been disabled. Additional comments may not be added to this entry at this time.